Humza Yousaf faces knife-edge confidence vote after collapse of Scottish coalition

Gain access to the Editor's Digest for no charge.

Every week, Roula Khalaf, the Chief Editor of the Financial Times, chooses her preferred and most interesting stories for her newsletter.

Humza Yousaf, who is the first minister of Scotland, is on the verge of being given a vote of no confidence. Several opposition parties are taking a strong stance against him due to his decision to end his political party's coalition with the Scottish Greens.

On Thursday, the leader of the Scottish National party expressed his intention to rule with a minority administration. However, next week he will need to withstand a vote on a no-confidence motion presented by the Scottish Conservatives.

The Scottish Labour and Green parties have stated their support for the motion against Yousaf. In order to secure victory in the vote, Yousaf will have to seek support from sources outside of his own political party.

Lorna Slater, one of the leaders of the Greens, explained that their support was founded on the forward-thinking policies presented in the now-annulled Bute House collaboration deal.

She stated that because of his choice to terminate the agreement, the execution of the program has become uncertain. She mentioned various policies, including regulations on rental fees, prohibition of conversion therapy, and greater efforts to combat climate change.

Slater stated that there was no guarantee that his government, which lacks a majority, would pursue these goals.

The SNP of Yousaf has a total of 63 MSPs, while all the opposition parties together have 65. If there were to be a tie, the presiding officer of the parliament would vote in favor of the current situation.

The end of the partnership between SNP and Greens happened because Yousaf decided to drop a number of Scotland's climate goals last week, causing a lot of anger from his colleagues in charge.

During a recent media briefing held at Bute House in Edinburgh, the leader of the SNP announced that the agreement to share power had successfully achieved its goals. The leader also asserted that ending the agreement would offer the party an opportunity to govern as per its policy objectives.

Yousaf acknowledged that increasing their goals will be difficult as they are a minority government. However, he pointed out that the SNP had governed in the past without a majority.

"We must communicate with the entire nation using a unified message, and today signifies a fresh start for the SNP," he stated.

Yousaf rejected the idea that the choice revealed a vulnerability in the SNP and emphasized that he had demonstrated his ability to lead.

After the 2021 Holyrood election, the SNP fell short of the number of seats required to achieve a majority, prompting the formation of a coalition with the Greens.

On Thursday, Yousaf remarked that feelings were intense, but assured his commitment to collaborate with the Greens and other opposing political parties in crafting laws.

Slater stated that Humza Yousaf has demonstrated his lack of trustworthiness in political cooperation by ending the agreement in a weak and hopeless manner.

According to Slater, the Green party’s endeavors to establish a Scotland that is more equitable and ecologically sound have been consistently obstructed by the SNP. This has been observed in matters pertaining to oil and gas policies, as well as the country's emissions reduction targets for 2030.

Ross criticized Yousaf for his lack of strength, while proposing a motion of no confidence. In order for the motion to proceed to a vote, it requires the backing of 25 MSPs. The Conservative party, led by Ross, currently has 31 MSPs in support of the motion.

This week, there was a revelation of disagreement within the SNP as a group of six MSPs who hold nationalist views, which includes Kate Forbes, challenged a justice bill proposing to try rape cases with judges only. It's important to note that last year, Forbes ran against Yousaf for the leadership of the SNP.

Nonetheless, Forbes stated on Thursday that she would support Yousaf and had confidence in his ability to withstand the vote of no-confidence.