Rishi Sunak facing Tory revolt over plan to criminalise rough sleeping

Rishi Sunak

Get Expert Westminster Analysis In Your Inbox With View From Westminster Email

Receive Free Westminster Updates Via Email

Rishi Sunak is currently confronted with opposition from the Conservative party regarding his proposal to make homelessness illegal in a significant crime legislation that is set to be introduced this year.

The head of the government is in danger of facing opposition from members of parliament who sit in the back row during the vote on the Criminal Justice Bill. The bill would allow law enforcement to impose fines on or relocate homeless individuals who are considered to be causing a disturbance.

Many Members of Parliament (MPs) belonging to both the left and right factions of the Conservative Party have informed the Tory whips that they intend to vote against certain provisions in the bill.

The business minister, Kevin Hollinrake, declined to state whether he would endorse the proposals to make sleeping on the streets an offence.

According to reliable sources from the government, they have decided to temporarily stop the progress of the legislation until they can reach a compromise with over 40 members who are planning to oppose it.

One person commented that the government is extremely worried about the size of the rebellion since they're aware that if it is taken to a vote, they would be defeated.

The dissident stated: "Nevertheless, we won't concede or yield. It's up to the government to take action now. If they don't pay attention, they'll be in a dire situation."

On Monday, a government official declined to comment on whether or not they would endorse the proposal to make homelessness a criminal offense.

When questioned by Times Radio about whether he would support the current bill, the business minister Kevin Hollinrake responded that it was not his responsibility. He expressed his curiosity in observing the development of the legislation and discovering the plans of the prime minister.

When questioned about the legitimacy of detaining individuals for supposedly disturbing public order by sleeping rough, Mr Hollinrake stated that the top priority should be ensuring that adequate resources are available to assist individuals in finding a suitable place to reside. He also believes that there must be designated safe spaces where people in need can receive proper assistance.

In my personal opinion, I strongly believe that people should not have the choice to remain on the streets if there are available options for them to obtain shelter elsewhere. It is unfair for these individuals to be occupying public sidewalks and other areas, as it can create a disturbance for those who reside in the same town or city. It is important for everyone to have access to a suitable living environment and not be confined to the streets.

CEO Polly Neate from Shelter made a statement accusing the government of trying to penalize individuals for not having a home.

The current proposals would provide police and government employees with fresh abilities to instruct homeless individuals to relocate, while additionally urging them to utilize housing facilities and receive assistance for mental health issues.

The government will be introducing a fresh crime for gangs that plan out begging groups, according to a publication released by the government. They will also be removing people who cause problems on the street, specifically those who obstruct store entrances or request money at cash dispensers.

Charities working to support homeless individuals have cautioned that the recent measures introduced by the government to replace the Vagrancy Act, which outlawed rough sleeping for over two centuries, could actually lead to a deepening of the crisis by prosecuting and punishing those without a permanent residence.

The head of Shelter, Polly Neate, expressed her opposition to the proposed law, stating that it is not the right solution. Rather than penalizing individuals for their homelessness, lawmakers should focus on finding ways to keep them off the streets.

"Every individual who may be at risk of having to sleep on the streets should be entitled to proper emergency housing. To completely eradicate homelessness, there must be an investment made towards reasonably priced social homes, with at least 90,000 new ones per year being constructed."

The director of social change at Homeless Link, Fiona Colley, expressed her dissatisfaction with the proposal.

She stated that being homeless is not an offense. The government agreed to end the Vagrancy Act with the understanding that individuals sleeping on the streets require aid, not punishment.

We feel really let down by the fact that the new plan will lead to more vulnerable individuals being treated as criminals instead of providing effective solutions to help them get off the streets permanently.

The Liberal Democrats requested that the government rethinks their intention to turn homelessness into a crime. MP Layla Moran headed a group of politicians from various parties to eradicate the Vagrancy Act and stated: "The insensitive approach outlined in the Criminal Justice Bill could lead to the Vagrancy Act being reintroduced surreptitiously."

The authorities ought to pay attention to their MPs who support them and adopt a humane strategy towards addressing homelessness. They shouldn't label or punish those who sleep on the streets.

Choosing to sleep on the streets is not an intentional way of life. Leaders should prioritize addressing the underlying issues contributing to this problem instead of blaming those who are suffering from it.

A representative of the government declared: "We have a firm resolve to put an end to rough sleeping, and to ensure that individuals do not end up homeless in the first place. This is why we formulated our plan to permanently eliminate rough sleeping, which was released last year and is supported by a remarkable promise of £2 billion."

The Vagrancy Act, which was introduced way back in 1824, is no longer relevant and no one should be punished just for being homeless. That is precisely why we pledged to revoke this act.

These regulations offer a peaceful way to approach individuals who sleep in public spaces to aid them in accepting support offers. Only those who do not follow lawfully given directions, notices or orders are subject to penal action.

Read more
Similar news