Republican candidates split over Donald Trump, abortion and Ukraine at debate

Get the latest updates on the US presidential election 2024 without spending a penny.

You will receive a daily email from us, called myFT Daily Digest, summarizing the most recent updates on the US presidential election in 2024. This email will be sent to you every morning.

Donald Trump loomed large over the initial Republican presidential primary debate on Wednesday evening, as eight of his competitors engaged in heated discussions regarding his increasing legal troubles, while the ex-president opted out of the event to participate in an interview on a social media platform.

The live TV discussion and Trump's previously recorded conversation with ex-Fox News anchor Tucker Carlson on X, formerly known as Twitter, occurred one day prior to the ex-US president's intention to hand himself over to officials in Georgia. In this state, he is confronted with legal accusations connected to his attempts to invalidate the 2020 election.

The opponents of Trump have been cautious about openly criticizing the ex-president, who continues to hold the leading position among many candidates. However, a heated discussion arose when the subject of Trump's conduct was brought up.

Vivek Ramaswamy, the trailblazing individual in the biotechnology field who found himself in the midst of numerous controversial discussions, swiftly jumped to the defense of the former president who is facing charges. This generated conflicting opinions among others.

"Someone needs to put an end to accepting this behavior...the behavior is unacceptable for someone serving as the president of the United States," stated ex-Governor of New Jersey, Chris Christie, which led to disapproving reactions from the gathering of Republican voters.

"We must confront the reality that Trump is the most unpopular political figure in the United States," stated Nikki Haley, a former ambassador to the United Nations. "It is impossible to secure victory in a nationwide election with such disapproval."

During the debate, the moderators questioned the candidates regarding their opinion on former vice-president Mike Pence's actions on January 6, 2021. On that day, Pence officially affirmed Joe Biden's Electoral College win, despite the intrusion of Trump supporters into the US Capitol.

Governor Ron DeSantis of Florida evaded the question multiple times, until he abruptly responded, stating, "Mike fulfilled his responsibilities. I hold no grudges against him. However, are we truly going to dedicate our attention to dwelling on this topic from now on? The constant revisiting of it?"

Trump is confronted with over twelve criminal accusations in Georgia, alongside three imminent criminal proceedings in Manhattan, Miami, and Washington.

During his conversation with Carlson on X, which was made available online shortly before the debate in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Trump restated his unfounded allegations that the 2020 election was unfairly manipulated against him. He also pondered the possibility of facing political unrest, stating, "I have observed their actions and witnessed the extreme measures they are willing to take."

Five of the Republican contenders during the debate — DeSantis, Ramaswamy, Haley, Senator Tim Scott from South Carolina, and Governor Doug Burgum from North Dakota — indicated their agreement when questioned about their willingness to back Trump if he became the party's preferred candidate despite being found guilty of a crime.

The remaining three individuals, Christie, Pence, and former Arkansas governor Asa Hutchinson, did not.

According to the most recent collection of national polls by FiveThirtyEight, Trump has the backing of slightly more than 50% of Republican voters. In contrast, DeSantis falls far behind in second place with only 14% of support, while the other candidates have even lower single-digit percentages.

The discussion moderators additionally questioned the contenders about the extent of limitations on abortion and if they would endorse an increase in financial aid for Ukraine's war endeavors.

The contenders held different views on abortion. Pence and Scott expressed their approval for a federal prohibition on abortions beyond the 15-week mark of pregnancy, whereas DeSantis and Hutchinson refrained from indicating their stance on endorsing more stringent federal restrictions concerning abortion.

You are viewing a still image of a dynamic visual. This is probably because you are not connected to the internet or have disabled JavaScript in your web browser.

Haley cautioned that advocating for a national prohibition on abortion would spell trouble for the GOP, particularly following their unsuccessful performance in the previous midterm elections. This outcome was attributed to the reversal of Roe vs Wade, which abolished the federal entitlement to terminate pregnancies and returned the matter to the jurisdiction of individual states.

Haley expressed that the power lies with the individuals, and this is the rightful place for it. She emphasized that no Republican leader can prohibit abortion and urged against pressurizing women to feel obligated in making a choice regarding this matter.

Ramaswamy, who joined the discussion with increased attention after making remarks this week insinuating that the US government might have played a role in the 9/11 attacks, faced severe criticism on multiple occasions.

During a heated argument, Pence, who is 64 years old, confronted the 38-year-old entrepreneur, stating that he lacked the necessary maturity and expertise for the presidency.

"This is not the moment to engage in on-the-job learning," stated Pence, who had previously served as the governor of Indiana and a member of Congress before assuming the role of vice-president. "We must avoid introducing an inexperienced individual."

Ramaswamy stood alone among all the contenders by openly expressing his stance against providing more financial assistance to Ukraine. He firmly asserted that the United States has different priorities that supersede Ukraine's needs.

Haley responded disapprovingly, condemning his limited understanding of international relations and his prioritization of Russian president Vladimir Putin over the interests of the United States.

"This individual is a killer, and you are opting for a killer instead of supporting a country that upholds democratic principles," she remarked.

Christie also directed criticism towards Ramaswamy, who has gained more support from voters in the past few weeks, expressing: "I am truly fed up with listening to a person who resembles ChatGPT speaking on this platform tonight."

Further analysis conducted by Oliver Roeder based in New York