Phillip Schofield’s TV comeback Cast Away is one of the weirdest yet
Sign Up For Free Real-Time News Alerts!
Subscribe For Free Breaking News Alerts
Subscribe For Free Breaking News Alerts
I would appreciate receiving emails about promotions, events, and news from The Independent. Please take a look at our privacy policy.
It's a harsh turn of events: Phillip Schofield, who once dominated the morning TV scene, is now struggling to find basic necessities like food, water, and shelter on a remote island in Madagascar. Completely cut off from the outside world, his beard has grown wild. His only companions are the cameras from Channel 5 scattered across the island, capturing his experiences for the upcoming three-part series titled Phillip Schofield: Cast Away. This marks the 62-year-old host's return to television after being let go from ITV's This Morning last year due to a controversy surrounding his relationship with a much younger co-worker. It’s a comeback that many didn’t ask for, airing on a lesser-known network, featuring a man who appears uncertain about the purpose of this venture.
The former host of This Morning faced one of the most sensational media crises in recent times, culminating in Schofield frantically vaping during a series of open interviews. Did he break any laws? No. He referred to his dishonesty regarding his affair as “unwise but not illegal.” Was there an underlying tone of homophobia in the way the situation unfolded? Possibly—if you look through the flood of comments on social media about Schofield, it’s alarming to see how much of the vitriol directed at him stems from homophobia. Could people have distanced themselves any quicker? Probably not. One thing remains clear: we’re still figuring out how to approach the entire situation, and the same holds true on Cast Away. Schofield speaks extensively about the repercussions of the scandal—what he calls being “cancelled”—while mostly avoiding details of his actions. Although there may be a significant issue being overlooked, that doesn’t stop Schofield from emphasizing the evidence of it all with glaring indicators like footprints and tusk marks.
What’s the real reason behind the launch of Cast Away? For Channel 5, the answer is straightforward. The network, which has struggled with its outdated approach to programming, is leveraging Schofield’s controversial reputation to generate more buzz and media attention than it has experienced in a long time—maybe even years. In that sense, the show is already achieving its objective, despite the fact that audience reactions have been consistently unfavorable.
What’s even more puzzling is what Schofield really aimed to accomplish with his show, which seems heavily inspired by Alan Partridge. Is he trying to make a comeback? That seems like a plausible idea, but his attitude throughout the series feels less like a triumphant return and more like a final, weary farewell. Or maybe it's simply a chance for him to air his frustrations. At one point, he openly states, "I don’t care anymore, this is my chance to speak as I step away." There had been some rumors that Schofield might participate in "I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here!", a show often seen as the nail in the coffin for a celebrity's reputation – yet even that would likely have been a better option than what he's done here. In this isolated and somewhat low-budget struggle against nature, Schofield still has to contend with hunger and find a spot to relieve himself, but without the substantial paycheck from ITV or the lighthearted banter with Ant and Dec.
In the carefully staged scenes with Schofield and his family, filmed before his trip to the island, the show really comes off as a public relations effort. It seems aimed at restoring the presenter's image by portraying him as a sympathetic victim of a vicious and harmful hate campaign. More and more, celebrities facing controversies are turning to reality TV to repair their reputations, with recent examples like Matt Hancock and Nigel Farage. Later in the first episode, a visibly emotional Schofield discusses his thoughts of suicide from the previous year. This is a very serious topic and shouldn’t be treated lightly, even if it does come across as somewhat strategic in how it’s presented.
However, it's hard to ignore the absolute futility of the entire situation. Schofield expresses his frustration about the media's invasion of his privacy after the scandal, saying, “Leave me alone and let me enjoy the peaceful life you’ve all forced upon me,” while looking directly into the camera.
The program offers a fascinating look at what it means to be "canceled," especially for someone like Schofield, who spent years entertaining morning TV audiences. While actors who face cancellation often find opportunities in European or independent films, and novelists can keep writing, musicians can continue performing and recording, Schofield's situation is different. He doesn’t have a creative foundation to fall back on. His identity was centered around being a TV presenter, known for his friendly demeanor. However, with the public now viewing him as neither friendly nor trustworthy, his reputation has taken a hit, much like the disastrous Jet2 holiday experience he is associated with.
The charm of a cheerful morning host often lies in their ability to blend in seamlessly, as demonstrated by the incredibly dull new pair on This Morning, Cat and Ben. This is something he is likely aware of. In many respects, Cast Away fits this narrative perfectly: it serves as a platform for a man who has always been in front of the camera and seems not to ponder the reasons behind it. If this truly marks the end of Schofield's television presence, that’s one matter. However, having seen the Tom Hanks film, I find it hard to believe he won’t return eventually.
"Phillip Schofield: Cast Away" will be airing on Channel 5 at 9 PM on Tuesday, October 1st.
