UK Speaker Lindsay Hoyle faces calls to quit after Commons chaos

Gain access to the Editor's Digest without any cost.

Every week, Roula Khalaf, who is the Chief Editor at the Financial Times (FT), handpicks her preferred stories and includes them in her weekly newsletter.

People are demanding that Sir Lindsay Hoyle, who is the Speaker of the House of Commons, step down from his position. This comes after there was a lot of confusion and disorder in the chamber when they were discussing Gaza. Sir Lindsay Hoyle is getting ready to have discussions with different political party leaders.

Hoyle apologized for the disruption of the debate that took place on Wednesday night and expressed his remorse with strong emotions, taking full responsibility for it.

The Speaker disregarded the usual rules of Parliament in order to permit a proposal from the Labour Party to be added to a resolution initiated by the Scottish National party, which demanded an immediate end to the conflict between Israel and Hamas.

Over 50 individuals from the Conservative and Scottish National parties have signed a motion requesting that Hoyle, a former member of the Labour party, vacate his position as the Speaker. This role serves to be impartial while overseeing debates in the House of Commons. Previously, only 33 individuals had expressed their disapproval of the Speaker, however, the number has increased throughout Thursday.

It is anticipated that Hoyle will receive additional disapproval during the "business questions" session on Thursday, where the House of Commons leader Penny Mordaunt responds to queries from MPs. Members of the Labour party were encouraged to attend the session to offer Hoyle emotional backing.

On Wednesday, he went against the suggestions made by his Commons clerk when he decided to accept the Labour amendment regarding Gaza. The clerk had warned him that it went against tradition, but he proceeded with his decision anyway, causing several SNP and Tory MPs to leave the chamber.

Mordaunt has blamed Hoyle of taking a procedural choice that "weakens this House's trust" and then chose to remove Tory MPs from the voting process. The amendment introduced by the Labour party was passed in the Commons without any voting.

Even though Conservative leaders haven't openly demanded the Speaker's resignation, health minister Maria Caulfield declined to support him on Thursday morning.

During an interview with Sky News, she expressed that Hoyle was facing challenges due to the chaotic and disorderly behavior in the chamber on Wednesday night. She believed that the House of Commons was not displaying its usual high level of professionalism and that her trust in Lindsay had diminished as a result.

Stephen Flynn, who leads the SNP in Westminster, has raised doubts about Hoyle's continued tenure. He believes that it will be necessary to provide substantial evidence that Hoyle's position is still sustainable.

On Wednesday, the Speaker apologized and explained that he accepted the Labour amendment to the SNP motion and a government amendment due to fears of safety risks for MPs. Various Labour MPs who did not request a ceasefire in Gaza have faced threats and intimidating actions by furious protesters.

Mordaunt stated last night that her party did not request any favor like this: "We, who are on the other side of the House, did not request for the operations of this House to be changed just to avoid such difficulties, despite having undergone extreme abuse."

William Wragg, who serves as the chair of the committee for public administration and constitutional affairs, has presented a petition opposing Hoyle.