Sir Lindsay Hoyle facing motion of no confidence over House of Commons chaos - live
The Scottish National Party and Conservative Members of Parliament left the House of Commons due to their dissatisfaction with the Speaker's management of the Gaza vote.
Get Expert Westminster Analysis In Your Inbox With The View From Westminster Email
"Free Westminster Email View - Grab Now!"
Pressure on Sir Lindsay Hoyle to step down as speaker is growing, as 33 MPs signed a motion of no confidence against him on Wednesday night.
The individual speaking offered apologies following a tumultuous session in the House of Commons where members of Parliament from both the Government and SNP exited the room in a demonstration against his management of the discussion on the Gaza ceasefire.
The main point was that he made a choice to defy tradition and opt for the Labour proposal to modify the SNP motion that advocated for a "ceasefire" in Gaza and Israel. The modified motion was eventually approved without needing a vote.
Penny Mordaunt, who holds the position of Commons Leader, accused Sir Lindsay of taking over the conversation and causing doubts about the House's ability to function effectively.
Hence, she retracted the amendment proposed by the government, leading to a situation where Conservative and Scottish National Party Members of Parliament left the room.
Even though Sir Lindsay apologized to the chamber, 33 MPs signed a motion called Early Day Motion. The motion showed they have no confidence in the speaker. This happened on Wednesday night.
Over 30 MPs Back No Confidence Motion In Speaker
After the intense happenings at the House of Commons tonight, 33 members of parliament have expressed their lack of faith in Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle by signing a motion of no confidence.
The head of the backbench 1922 Committee, Sir Graham Brady, along with William Wragg and SNP members David Linden and Chris Law, have all signed the document.
Holly Evans, writing on 21 February 2024 at 9:15 PM.
"Protesters Demand Gaza Ceasefire As MPs Debate SNP Motion"
"Protesters Gather Outside Parliament As MPs Discuss SNP Motion On Gaza Ceasefire"
On Wednesday 21 February, a large group of people gathered outside the Houses of Parliament to protest against the conflict in Gaza. This coincided with a debate in Parliament, in which the Scottish National Party called for an end to the fighting. During the debate, there was controversy when Sir Lindsay Hoyle allowed a vote on a ceasefire proposed by the Labour party. Conservative and SNP MPs walked out of the chamber in response, calling for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire. Sir Lindsay later apologised and faced criticism.
On February 21, 2024 at 11pm, Holly Evans wrote a blog post.
Gaza Speaker's Good Intentions Backfired
Are the rules outdated? The Scottish National Party and Conservative MPs were extremely angry. They believed that these rules were old and extremely important, as they are part of the rights that British people (including the Scots) have been born with. They are meant to guarantee our democratic freedoms. However, upon closer inspection, these rules were created back in the year 1979.
Check out the complete piece by John Rentoul by clicking this link.
Holly Evans posted a blog on February 21, 2024 at 10:00 pm.
Charity CEO Displeased By 'Political Theatrics' In Gaza Debate
The CEO of CARE International UK, Helen McEachern, expressed her disappointment with the political drama happening in the House of Commons. She believes that debating about parliamentary procedure does not help the people of Gaza in any way. Unfortunately, these people have no alternative but to live in conditions that are undignified and dangerous. They continue to suffer from bombings and illnesses, resulting in countless deaths.
If a continuous and prompt stop of conflict doesn't happen, they won't get the essential resources such as food, water, and medical facilities that are essential to save lives and avoid additional harm.
During my recent trip to the West Bank, our team and associates from Gaza informed me that the situation is worsening each day. There is an increase in fatalities, illnesses, and starvation. The number of widows and orphans is on the rise. Is it reasonable to delay taking action while more females endure C-sections and minors undergo amputations without proper pain relief?
It is imperative that the Foreign Secretary takes every measure possible to bring an end to the devastating humanitarian situation we are currently witnessing. The violent clashes must come to a halt, and the provisions of aid must be facilitated. The release of all hostages must be secured and all sides involved in the conflict must adhere to global humanitarian regulations.
"Home Secretary Apologizes For Defaced Birth Certificate"
The person in charge of Home Affairs has expressed regret to a household regarding a birth document of a child being handed back damaged. They also stated that an external company working with the department has halted a number of their employees.
James Cleverly has instructed an inquiry to be carried out on Monday, following a report from the Campaign Against Antisemitism, which stated that the birth certificate had been returned to the family with the word Israel blotted out.
On Wednesday night, he shared a post on X, which used to be called Twitter, where he said sorry to the family for the hurt they experienced. Additionally, he said that he has requested a quick examination into an incident where a birth certificate was damaged.
As we gather information, our business associate has temporarily let go of some employees.
This circumstance is completely inappropriate. We will not endure any form of hostility towards Jewish people.
On February 21st, 2024 at 9:48 pm, Holly Evans posted on her blog.
"Hamas Must Change For Lasting Ceasefire" - David Cameron
Foreign Secretary, Lord Cameron, stated that a truce in Gaza that permits Hamas to maintain control will not be enduring.
The speaker stated that the Prime Minister and himself have mentioned a series of requirements. These requirements include the release of hostages, the evacuation of Hamas leaders from Gaza, the dismantling of terrorist infrastructure, the possibility of political change for Palestinians, and the establishment of a new Palestinian government.
Stopping the fighting requires more than just requesting a ceasefire. You must take additional measures.
In the news, it has been reported that David Cameron believes that a truce or ceasefire with Hamas whilst they are in control, wouldn't be a long-lasting solution. The former Prime Minister has expressed his doubts regarding any agreements made with the group.
Naturally, a ceasefire is not likely to hold up if Hamas remains present and continues to launch rockets, with the potential for another October 7 to occur. Therefore, conditions would need to be met in order for the ceasefire to be successful.
The optimal approach is to utilize a method that results in a lasting truce without reverting back to hostilities. This is our way of achieving it.
Merely uttering the phrase "we should stop fighting now" without any noticeable alteration in the actions of Hamas will not result in a sustainable ceasefire.
Holly Evans posted a blog on February 21st, 2024 at 9:29 PM.
MP Applauds Speaker's Actions
When questioned about the disorderly events in the House of Commons, John Healey, a leading member of the Labour Party, remarked that Sir Lindsay Hoyle was making the correct decision.
He stated: "We've exhibited the lowest point of Westminster, a dispute revolving around protocol in which the Conservatives abstained from the voting process, and the SNP departed."
This has no positive impact on the Palestinian people and does not contribute to the promotion of peace.
When questioned about whether or not Labour still trusts Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle, Mr. Healey responded that the Speaker was actively attempting to facilitate a widespread discussion pertaining to matters of Parliament, community, and global importance.
Sir Lindsay Hoyle has expressed regret after Members of Parliament from the Scottish National Party (SNP) and the Conservative Party staged a walkout during proceedings at the House of Commons.
The UK Parliament's House of Commons has released a new report through the PA Wire.
"He was behaving appropriately."
Responding to claims that Labour was using the issue for political gain, he expressed his disapproval towards the SNP for making such accusations when their only intention was to criticize Labour.
"After they were unsuccessful in their debates inside the room, they departed."
Starmer: Tories And SNP Prioritize Politics Over People
When he first responded to today's disorder, Sir Keir Starmer blamed the Conservative Party and the Scottish National Party for prioritizing political tactics over genuine remedies.
Following the departure of certain SNP and Conservative MPs from the parliamentary session pertaining to the Gaza ceasefire discourse, the Labour leader expressed their thoughts through a statement. They mentioned that the day presented an opportunity for Parliament to come together and speak collectively about the dreadful circumstances in Gaza and Israel.
Labour proposed an amendment that called for an urgent humanitarian pause in the conflict. This pause would need to last and be respected by both parties involved, and it would ensure that hostages are released and aid reaches Gaza. Additionally, the amendment acknowledges that Israel has the right to protect itself from any future incidents like the one on October 7th. Most importantly, the amendment requires a plan for creating two states, indicating the gravity of the situation.
Regrettably, both the Conservatives and the SNP made a mutual decision to abandon the vote, showing no interest in addressing this important issue. Instead of finding effective solutions, they chose to indulge in political maneuvers.
It is evident that Labour is the only political group that has a solid strategy for the issues England is currently facing, both domestically and internationally. What's even more apparent is that Labour is the sole organization willing to prioritize the country's welfare over partisan interests and nonsensical political maneuvers to achieve results.
The article that follows was written by Holly Evans and released on February 21th, 2024 at 8:45 pm. Rewritten: This blog post is authored by Holly Evans and was published on February 21, 2024, at 8:45 in the evening.
Stephen Flynn Alleges Labour Blocked SNP's Gaza Motion
The leader of the SNP in the Westminster, Stephen Flynn, made the same statement on social media that his party's motion for a ceasefire in Gaza had been prevented from being voted on by the Labour party and the Speaker of the Commons, Sir Lindsay Hoyle.
He shared a message on X (formerly known as Twitter) saying that today was meant to be a day of ceasefire in Gaza.
That's why the SNP put forward the motion. The Speaker and Labour Party caused Westminster to prevent us from having a straightforward vote.
"Our commitment to advocating for those who are experiencing hardship due to this crisis will persist."
On February 21, 2024 at 8:30 PM, Holly Evans wrote in the blog.
MP Utterly Dismayed By Chaotic Proceedings In Parliament
Pete Wishart expressed surprise at the events that took place in the House of Commons on Wednesday, stating that he had never witnessed anything of that nature during his over two decades of service as an SNP MP.
The Member of Parliament (MP) representing Perth and North Perthshire, who was voted in during 2001, expressed his strong disapproval and shock regarding the recent events that took place in the House of Commons.
We came here with honest intentions to propose a motion for a prompt ceasefire in Gaza, but unfortunately, we were unable to present our argument today.
The discussion was taken over by the Labour Party.
He stated: "Surely, those who witnessed these proceedings would feel repulsed by what they have witnessed. This was a crucial day, where utmost attention was required and deserved. However, what unfolded was a complete circus, and the Speaker of the House of Commons is solely responsible for the chaos."
When questioned if he had witnessed anything similar during his stint as an MP, he replied, "Without a doubt, never before have I come across such a phenomenon."
"I have traveled through Iraq and experienced all the events related to the independence referendum and Brexit. However, I have never encountered a day quite similar to this one."
Holly Evans wrote a blog post on 21 February 2024 at 8:21 pm.
