Gary Lineker criticised over Rwanda comments in impartiality row

Gary Lineker

The picture featured in this blog post was taken by Ian Walton.

Fresh inquiries are arising about the recently implemented neutrality regulations of BBC.

Gary Lineker - Figure 1
Photo BBC News

Gary Lineker is under fire once again for supporting a movement that is pushing for the dismissal of the government's proposal to transport refugees to Rwanda.

A group of famous people, including him, has put their signature on a letter that's publicly available, demanding politicians to take action and develop a "just and equitable strategy for asylum seekers".

Grant Shapps, who is in charge of the country's defense, raised concerns over whether the presenter of Match of the Day should share their political opinions.

Earlier this year, the BBC made it clear that they have specific rules regarding impartiality. Lineker stated that he did not violate any of these guidelines.

The company stated that Lineker could express his thoughts publicly "as long as they do not go against his BBC responsibilities; do not break the rules on conflicts of interest; or tarnish the reputation of the BBC". Additionally, they pointed out that Lineker did not make his recent move on any social media platform.

The letter was posted on the website of Together With Refugees campaign coalition when MPs are about to vote on the Safety of Rwanda Bill. The bill was previously rejected by the Supreme Court, but Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is making another attempt to get it approved.

A few MPs claimed that Lineker, who is the BBC's most highly paid employee according to their public disclosure, violated the BBC rules by getting involved in political parties.

According to Mr Shapps, it would be preferable if the individual in question stopped interfering in matters beyond football. While signing letters may be admirable, it would be advisable for him to concentrate solely on football.

Once the letter was made public, Conservative lawmaker Jonathan Gullis denounced it as "another instance where Gary Lineker has violated the BBC's mandate for impartiality."

However, Lineker answered back by saying, "Jonathan has not perused the latest instructions... or rather, someone needs to read them aloud to him."

Together With Refugees, the group coordinating the effort, has released an open letter that advocates for the establishment of a fresh system that aligns with the desires of the British populace.

The government is still attempting to deport individuals who seek refuge from persecution to Rwanda, even though the country's highest court has declared the practice to be illegal.

The written document criticizes the refugee system in the UK, stating that it has become increasingly unsympathetic, disorganized, and expensive.

The picture was captured by Hannah McKay. Brexit talks stall once again as the EU and UK are yet to reach an agreement on key issues. Negotiations on Brexit have once again come to a halt as the European Union and the United Kingdom have failed to come to an agreement on crucial matters.

The Defense Secretary, Grant Shapps, has a strong disagreement with Lineker.

Several other people who have signed the document are: Brian Cox and David Morrissey who are both actors, Suzi Ruffell who is a comedian, Big Zuu who is a TV chef, and Helen Pankhurst who campaigns for women's rights.

Lineker was one of only a few people who provided distinct statements for the organization's statement. In his statement, he said that we require a fresh framework that mirrors the desires of the British public, who have welcomed individuals into their residences, given donations, and volunteered in their neighborhoods.

"That is the reason why I am supporting this fresh crusade - due to the fact that equity can truly initiate at this point."

Lee Anderson, the deputy chairman of the Conservative party, expressed agreement with Gary's stance in an interview with the Daily Mail. He emphasized the importance of a system that aligns with the desires of the British public, which involves preventing boats from entering and telling highly paid snack vendors to keep quiet. Anderson's remarks suggest he is in support of a tougher approach to immigration and potentially stricter controls on the UK's border.

Before, the BBC mentioned that Lineker's widespread recognition brought about "extra obligations".

The BBC established specific instructions for their employees in news and current events who use social media to uphold their objective of neutrality. Recently, they reevaluated the implementation of these rules for other personnel and independent contractors.

The reason for this decision was due to the negative response that Lineker received after making remarks about Suella Braverman, a former home secretary, in March. Consequently, many notable figures in the BBC Sport industry refused to work in protest of Lineker's view that the employment regulations did not pertain to him.

Following an evaluation, the BBC compiled a roster of individuals, Lineker among them, who were deemed as "top-tier hosts".

The individuals who host the most prominent shows that are not related to news or current events have the duty to uphold the neutrality of the BBC. This is because they have a noticeable influence on the BBC due to their popularity.

The picture was taken by Nick Potts.

Lineker backed the fresh guidelines for social media introduced by the BBC.

As a top presenter, Lineker is allowed to share his opinions on topics that are important to him, but he must avoid actions that the BBC considers political campaigning.

The recent guidelines also acknowledge the value of the right to speak freely, however, it stipulates that during the broadcast of a show and for two weeks prior and following the series, hosts on prominent programs should refrain from either promoting or criticizing a political group.

Additionally, they must refrain from denouncing the personality of specific UK politicians or offering opinions on political topics during times of election (although the UK is presently not in one). They also cannot assume an official position for a campaign organization.

After the newly released guidance was made available, Lineker expressed on X that the updated regulations appear "reasonable and practical."

A representative from BBC mentioned that Gary, who works as a freelance presenter, has the freedom to participate in assignments for other organizations. But, there are certain conditions that should be met. Gary cannot be involved in any project that contradicts his responsibilities with BBC. Also, it is essential that he abides by the guidelines regarding conflicts of interest. Lastly, he regularly meets these criteria and ensures that the BBC's reputation is not at risk due to his actions.

On Monday, the BBC included an update stating that although people are permitted to discuss important matters, they must do so in a respectable manner and refrain from attacking an individual's character. Any concerns with presenters regarding this issue will be addressed and handled accordingly.

"Stay Tuned For Further Details"

Read more
Similar news
This week's most popular news