Live Aid promoter dismisses ‘woke do-gooders’ questioning Band Aid
Subscribe To Roisin O’Connor's Music Newsletter
Subscribe To Our Free Now Hear This Email!
Subscribe For Free To Our Now Hear This Email
I would love to receive emails regarding promotions, events, and news from The Independent. Please take a look at our privacy policy for more information.
The organizer behind the charity concert Live Aid has entered the discussion surrounding a new version of Band Aid’s charity song, “Do They Know It’s Christmas?”.
Harvey Goldsmith, the promoter responsible for the 1985 Live Aid concert and a collaborator with icons like Sir Elton John, Queen, The Who, Bruce Springsteen, Shania Twain, and Madonna, brushed aside the criticism from what he referred to as “nosy busybodies and overly sensitive do-gooders” regarding the song.
These comments follow Ed Sheeran's revelations about the 2014 version of the song. He mentioned that his views on the charity aspect have shifted and that he would have turned down the opportunity to be part of the new remix if he had been approached.
"We wanted to take action and make a difference. It's really that straightforward. Those who are constantly criticizing and claiming to have all the answers, they should step up and actually do something," Goldsmith said during an interview with Times Radio on Monday, November 25.
"In the past seven months, we've allocated £2.7 million to that area, four decades later. We've backed numerous causes, and the five of us who initiated this project have never received any financial compensation."
Goldsmith expressed that he found it odd how the media is exaggerating the situation or attempting to make it seem more significant than it actually is.
In a post he shared on Instagram last week, Sheeran expressed, "I wasn't asked for my permission regarding the new Band Aid 40 release, and if I had the option, I would have politely chosen not to allow my vocals to be used."
"Ten years later, my perspective on this topic has evolved, beautifully articulated by [Fuse ODG]. This is just my individual viewpoint, and I hope it’s one that looks ahead. Sending love to everyone."
Sheeran also shared Fuse ODG’s comments explaining his reasons for rejecting the charity single, as he had already declined an invitation to join the 2014 version.
Experience limitless listening with 100 million songs and podcasts, all without ads, thanks to Amazon Music.
Register today for a complimentary 4-month trial (3 months if you're not a Prime member).
Experience endless listening with 100 million songs and podcasts free from ads on Amazon Music.
Enroll today to enjoy a complimentary 4-month trial (3 months for those without a Prime membership)!
"Although they may evoke compassion and financial support, these portrayals reinforce harmful stereotypes that hinder Africa’s economic development, tourism, and investment. In the long run, this results in significant financial losses for the continent and undermines its dignity, pride, and sense of identity," he stated.
"By using images that strip individuals of their humanity, these efforts promote sympathy instead of collaboration, making it harder to foster genuine connections."
"Ed Sheeran has the right to express himself," Goldsmith commented. "He's made his views known, and he's also heard from someone named Fuse, who I honestly haven't heard of before. I wish them all the best."
"To be truthful, our goal and what we’re able to accomplish... After 40 years, we continue to receive funding. We focus on distributing these funds exclusively to projects. We do not cover any administrative costs at all. We're doing our utmost to make a difference. If someone disapproves, that's not our concern."
The Independent has reached out to Sheeran and Fuse's representatives for a response.
In an interview with The Sunday Times, Geldof, age 73, spoke up in support of the song's ongoing impact in raising money for people in need.
"This catchy pop song has helped millions survive," he mentioned while outlining the charity's efforts in areas like education and healthcare. "Why would Band Aid stop providing meals for thousands of children who rely on us for food? Why not continue that support? Is it really worth pausing these efforts over a vague debate from the wealthy world, no matter how valid it might be?"
He went on to say, “No matter how heartfelt an idea may be, it shouldn't prevent us from acknowledging the harsh truth of the situation. Right now, there are 600 million people facing hunger globally, with 300 million of them in Africa. We wish things were different, but that’s the reality. We can help a portion of those in need, and that’s what we will keep striving to do.”
To celebrate the 40th anniversary of the song's original release, first arranged by Geldof in 1984, a new all-star version has been created. This version combines the vocals and performances from the original, along with those from the 2004 and 2014 covers.
The new version showcases a range of notable performances from artists such as Robbie Williams, Ed Sheeran, Guy Garvey, One Direction, Simon Le Bon, Boy George, Sting, Chris Martin, Seal, as well as tributes from the late George Michael and Sinead O’Connor.
You can listen to the song now on streaming services, and it will be available on vinyl and CD starting November 29.
